JK15005Research 1~3-Seminar (KBR)(Lecture)

Numbering Code G-LET36 6JK15 LE36 Year/Term 2022 ・ Second semester
Number of Credits 2 Course Type special lecture
Target Year Target Student
Language English Day/Period Wed.5
Instructor name Tao PAN (Graduate School of Letters Program-Specific Senior Lecturer)
Outline and Purpose of the Course This course is designed for the study foci “Knowledge, Belief and Religion” (KBR) and “Visual, Media and Material Cultures” (VMC) and consists of the following three parts:
I. Silk Road in and between Asia and Europe;
II. Buddhist Art as Cultural Entanglement;
III. Manuscript Cultures as Transformative Creativity.
Course Goals Based on the theories of Transcultural Studies, this course offers numerous concrete examples for transculturality in the visual and material aspect as well as from the perspectives of creation and dissemination of knowledge and contact between religious networks on the macroscopic scale. Investigations on the microscopic scale, on the other hand, are concerned with how the formative and transformative processes result in certain cultural manifestations in the spheres of Buddhist art and manuscript cultures.
Schedule and Contents I. Silk Road in and between Asia and Europe
Week #01 Silk Road A Greater Picture Part 1
1.1. Asia in Old Persian inscriptions
1.2. India in early Greek literature
1.3. Case Study: Names of Rome in Chinese sources vs. Name of China in foreign sources
1.4. Case Study: Indika by Megasthenes and Arrian

Brief overview of course content
Old Persian script ~ example of transculturality (for scripts, cf. later sessions)
Topic for discussion: names and naming trends (in Europe, Asia, USA, etc.)
Rome: Da-qin 大-秦 great-Qin , Fu-lin 拂菻
China in Sanskrit, Greek (ser), Latin (Seres) sources.

Week #02 Silk Road A Greater Picture Part 2
2.1. Sogdians as Cultural Brokers
2.2. Turfan as Contact Zone
2.3. Chang’an as Cosmopolitan Terminal
Old Persian script ~ example of transculturality
Trade routes of Sogdians: https://sogdians.si.edu/historic-trade-routes-of-the-sogdians/
Sogdian Ancient Letters https://sogdians.si.edu/ancient-letters/
Read Letter 1, 2, 3.
Nanaia goddess: https://kimon.hosting.nyu.edu/sogdians/items/show/1150
https://kimon.hosting.nyu.edu/sogdians/items/browse
Religious adaptability of the Sogdians, by turns Mazdeans, Buddhists, Nestorians, Manichaeans and Muslims, according to their political and commercial interests
Manichaeism
Chang’an & Heian-kyo
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heian-kyo

References: Kent 1953 Old Persian grammar, texts, lexicon; Karttunen 1989 India in early Greek literature; Hansen 2017 The Silk Road: A New Documentary History to 1400: A New History with Documents. 2nd Edition; Sogdian Ancient Letters (by Sims-Williams, Livsic, La Vaissiere, Grenet); La Vaissiere 2005 Sogdian traders: a history; La Vaissiere 2005 Les sogdiens en Chine; Lieu 2013 The 'Romanitas' of the Xi'an Inscription; The Oxford dictionary of late antiquity; Boyce 1975 A reader in Manichaean Middle Persian and Parthian.

Week #03 Tarim Basin as Contact Zone Part 1
3.1. The Great Game from transcultural perspectives
3.2. German Expeditions (Grunwedel, Le Coq, Bartus)
3.3. French Expedition (Pelliot)

Week #04 Tarim Basin as Contact Zone Part 2
4.1. British Expedition (Hoernle, Macartney, Stein)
4.2. Russian Expedition (Oldenburg, Petrovski)
4.3. Japanese Expedition (Otani)
4.4. Chinese Expedition (Huang Wenbi)
Matsunami collection in Tokyo University
References: Hansen 2017 The Silk Road; Seiiki koko zufu 西域考古図譜. Kagawa Mokushiki 香川黙識 (ed.), 1915, 2 vols;
Website: http://idp.bl.uk , https://www.metmuseum.org , http://turfan.bbaw.de/dta/ , http://dsr.nii.ac.jp/toyobunko/index.html.ja ,

II. Buddhist Art as Cultural Entanglement
Week #05 Buddhist Art Part 1
5.1. Gandhara and the Greeks
5.2. Kucha and Kizil Caves
Gandhara Art, Language Gandhari (loan words from Middle Iranian, Script from Aramaic, )
Indian + Greek (Hadda, Afghanistan), Coins, Aniconic

Week #06 Buddhist Art Part 2
6.1. Dunhuang Caves as Time Capsules
6.2. Khotan as Entryway into Kucha and Turfan
Rhie Early Buddhist Art of China and Centra Asia

References: Gandhara BAW 2013; The Art of Gandhara in The Metropolitan Museum of Art; Pakistan. Terre de rencontre Ier-VIe siecle. Les arts du Gandhara (Musee Guimet); Alt-Kutscha; Altbuddhistische Kultstatten in Chinesisch-Turkistan; Die buddhistische Spatantike in Mittelasien 7 vols; Schlingloff 1981 Erzahlung und Bild (updated chin. version in 2013); Duan Wenjie 1994 Dunhuang Art; Ancient Khotan 2 vols; Serindia 5 vols; 中央アジア 世界美術大全集 東洋編15;
Website: https://www.metmuseum.org ; https://www.metmuseum.org ; http://dsr.nii.ac.jp/toyobunko/index.html.ja


Week #07 Visual and Textual Interplay Part 1
Focus: Names and Depictions of Certain Figures (Gods, Animals, Buddhist Monks, etc.)
7.1. Narrative Elements in the Buddhist Stories
7.2. Variations of Depiction and Concept of Open Philology
7.3. Case Study: Tigress Story in Various Transmissions

Week #08 Visual and Textual Interplay Part 2
Dieter Schlingloff: Erzahlung und Bild
Depiction of development of story and several episodes
Rock Art of Honey Hunters, 6000 BC
Lion Hunt of Ashurbanipal, Assyrian 7th cent. BC
Blinding of Polyphemos, Laconian Black Figure Cup, c. 540 BCE.
Cyclops Polyphemus Eleusis Amphora: funerary proto-Attic amphora circa 660 BC
Drinking cup (kylix) depicting Kirke from the Odyssey Greek Archaic Period 『千と千尋の神隠し』(せんとちひろのかみかくし)
Bharhut Bull and Tiger Jataka (Schiefner) by Asoka 3rd cent. BC
Jataka 357 Latukika, Bharhut, 2nd cent. BC
Miracle of the Buddha walking on a River Sanchi East Gateway 1st cent. BC
Sikri Stupa in Homage to Buddha Dipamkara in Gandhara Kushan 4th cent. AD
Josua begegnet einem Engel. Pal.gr.431.pt.B (https://digi.vatlib.it/mss/detail/215228)


III. Manuscript Cultures as Transformative Creativity
Week #09 Western Manuscripts
9.1. General Introduction
9.2. Western Manuscripts (Greek, Latin, Old Church Slavonic, Gothic, Old English, etc.)

Week #10 Oriental Manuscripts
10.1. General Introduction
10.2. Oriental Manuscripts (Gandhari, Sanskrit, Khotanese, Tocharian, Chinese, etc.)
10.3. Differences and Similarities between Western and Oriental Manuscripts

References: Manuscript Cultures Mapping the Field; One-Volume Libraries Composite and Multiple-Text Manuscripts
Website: Homer (Venetus A): http://beta.hpcc.uh.edu/hmt/archive-dl/VenetusA/ ; Aeneas: https://digi.vatlib.it/view/MSS_Vat.lat.3867 ; Gothic: http://www.alvin-portal.org/alvin/view.jsf?pid=alvin-record%3A173610&dswid=7503 ; Old High German: http://www.handschriftencensus.de/werke ; Old English: https://ebeowulf.uky.edu/ebeo4.0/CD/main.html ; Sanskrit: http://idp.bbaw.de/ ; Gandhari: https://gandhari.org/ ; Avestan: https://ada.geschkult.fu-berlin.de

Week #11 Composite Manuscripts Part 1
11.1. Textually Composite (Buddhist, Jaina, China; Bilingual)
11.2. Physically Composite (two layers, glued or sewn)

Week #12 Composite Manuscripts Part 2
12.1. Philosophical/Religious Encounters between Asia and Europe
12.2. Case Study: Manichaeism in Tocharian und Old Turkic; Toch B-Uighur Bilingual Hymn to Mani

References: The Emergence of Multiple-Text Manuscripts; Hartmann Wille Skt Handschriften Sammlung Pelliot 3510 Sammelhandschriften; Hartmann 2017 SHT 7185; Pan/Chen 2021 Traces of Chinese Buddhist Scrolls in Fragments of Tocharian Pothis; von Gabain/Winter 1958 Ein Hymnus an den Vater Mani auf “Tocharisch” B mit altturkischer Ubersetzung; Pinault 2008 Bilingual hymn to Mani: Analysis of the Tocharian B parts

Week #13 Production of Manuscripts
13.1. Production of Palm Leaf Manuscripts
13.2. Chinese Buddhist Scrolls Transformed into Tocharian Pothis (How & Why & When & Where)

Week #14 Manuscript Forgeries
14.1. Manuscript Forgeries as Transcultural Case Study
14.2. Unknown Script or Forgery? Hoernle Biscript

References: Sims-Williams 2000 Forgeries from Chinese Turkestan in the British Library’s Hoernle and Stein Collections; Dunhuang Manuscript Forgeries 2002; Rosen 2001 Hedin Forgery; Fakes and Forgeries of Written Artefacts from Ancient Mesopotamia to Modern China; Dragoni Schoubben Peyrot 2020 The Formal Kharosthi script from the Northern Tarim Basin in Northwest China may write an Iranian language
Website: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1G7Nd5Y6UCE

Week #15 Review of Course Materials
Evaluation Methods and Policy Assessment will be based on class performance (50% = attendance 20% + one presentation 30%) and final assignment (50%)
To JDTS/MATS students: This course can be taken as either reduced (4 ECTS) or full seminar (8 ECTS). Please indicate your ECTS requirement to the teacher.
Course Requirements None
Study outside of Class (preparation and review) Students will be required to read the materials in advance and come prepared to discuss them.
PAGE TOP